Straight guys first time gay

Top 10 Straight First Timers

66.3k 100% 31min - 1080p

FTM Jock Rubs Pussy And Uses Vibrator

314.3k 100% 8min - 1080p

'Gay For Pay' Straight Guys Have First Gay Fuck

204.2k 100% 12min - 1080p

1st time raw sex practice for str8 roomie before his party

581.3k 100% 10min - 1080p

Asked my teen friend to suck my dick, it was his first time!

2.2M 100% 11min - 1080p

2 guys that were totally straight stayed over and wacked off while being recorded unknowingly

261k 100% 12min - 1080p

The project continues and ASG 2.0 coming Online Now!! All of our AmateurStraightGuys Videos are coming back, restored and enhanced into HD, UHD, and 4K!

64.9k 99% 13min - 1080p

Straight Guys Share Bed And Fuck Hard

836.9k 100% 10min - 1080p

Str8 Shool Military Male Gets Raw Cock 1st Time

141.1k 100% 8min - 1080p

Sexy Inked Up Hunk's First Ever Time

627.9k 100% 10min - 1080p

Closeted Army Hunk Has First Gay Fuck With Bunkmate

277.3k 100% 20min - 1080p

NextDoorStudios - Straight Boys Carter & Jayden Explore Their Gay Side

490.8k 100% 13min - 1080p

Reality Dudes - Peyton

50.3k 100% 6min - 1080p

Young guy sucks and fucks for money for the first time with persistent dominant Oliver Strelly Falcon Al - 93

169.3k 100% 6min - 1080p

Young Amateur Straight Boy Gay For Pay Sex For 10k Pesos With Stranger POV

986k 100% 8min - 1080p

Str8 Military Guys First Ever Raw Fucking His Friend And Cum

202.5k 100% 10min - 1080p

First time anal with front cam - Stepneph' "I'll Teach You How To Fuck!" - NextDoorTwink - cute small bottoms twink cumming - Amateur gayUncl' fucks bottom skinny whiteboy and cums with him - teasing and jacking off - with Alex B

295.5k 100% 48min - 1080p

First Time With Mindful Escort

897.3k 100% 25min - 1080p

Twink has gay sex for the first time with Leo (PREVIEW 2) - Leo & Tommy

135.7k 99% 7min - 1080p

Hot straight bi curious want to fuck my ass ,, hard to say no to that . its slways a hot fuck.

545.2k 6% 10min - 1080p

Straight men have never done this before and decide to give it a try to masturbate at the same time

394.7k 91% 12min - 1080p

Las Vegas Boys Starring Trevor&Bryan&Cypher : Now in High Def and Ultra High Def! See them like you've never seen them before ONLY on ASG this Summer 2022! See the Xvideo

51.9k 99% 20min - 1080p

Gotta love spy cams when there are two guys that claim to be straight

298.7k 81% 12min - 1080p

Straight guy plays with gay guy for the 1st time

149.4k 100% 9min - 1080p

Dude, i´m not bisexual! We Shouldn’t Do This, I Like Ur Sis'! - Hunk Down On tattoed Twink - Curious And Insecure Tatooed Twink Gets Sex Advice First Hand From muscle B' in law - with Alex Barcelona

917k 100% 25min - 1080p

Straight Guys Try Gay Sex At The Office

1.5k 82% 18min - 1080p